Early in the spring of 2009 when the debate over the expansion of singletrack riding in Forest Park was gathering steam, I met up with members of the Northwest Trail Alliance (NWTA, formerly Portland United Mountain Pedalers or PUMP) for a ride in the park. That evening, a palpable sense of momentum hung in the air.

The group had recently begun ratcheting up their efforts to expand access to Forest Park, where despite being the country’s largest urban park at 5,000 acres, there exists just one-third of a mile for singletrack riding. The talk that afternoon was of “trail sharing”; a plan that would allow knobby tires on a few narrow, more contoured hiker-only trails during certain days a week. The informal proposal had gotten the spokes rolling again on an issue that PUMP had been founded on back in the 1980s: access to Forest Park.

It also kicked up a cloud of controversy. Not only was there the 1995 Forest Park Natural Resource Management Plan to contend with (the near mythical document relegates bikes to paths at least 8-feet wide) there were also groups such as the Portland Audubon Society and the Forest Park Conservancy who worried that allowing bikes on anything but the 28 miles worth of firelanes that are already available to them, would irrevocably erode the park’s trails, damage its fragile ecology, and possibly even put hikers at risk due to close encounters with bikes.

Covering the issue for the magazine, I literally went along for a ride to see how the effort was going.

Despite the formidable resistance, NWTA members were optimistic that night. Portland Parks and Recreation Commissioner Nick Fish, who had said he had wanted to investigate “low-hanging fruit” within the park, appeared eager to move on the issue. And with endorphins flowing after skirting our way down the park’s rarified patch of single-track (a section that was legally constructed off of Firelane 5, deep within the park, several years back), everyone circled their bikes around and thought about what might be. Spring had arrived. The days had begun to stretch longer, and a summer of riding—maybe even on new trails in Forest Park—felt within reach. Anything seemed possible.

Then I noticed something funny. A strange hiss had begun to rise up from my back tire. I looked down. Inexplicably the tube had begun ballooning outward. The hiss got louder. Horrified I watched as my tire bulged out and out and out—sssssssssssssssss—and finally… BANG! The sucker exploded like a gunshot. The reverberations appeared to shake the trees. My tube had been obliterated, and my tire was shredded. Dumbfounded, the hardened group of mountain bikers looked on. What the hell just happened everyone wondered?

I still don’t really know what made my tube detonate. I did know that I wasn’t going anywhere until I figured out how to fix my tire on the fly. Luckily, a NTWA member whipped out an empty pack silver package of energy goo, and after I aired up a spare tube, he crammed the wrapper down between the lacerated tire and the wheel’s rim, enabling me to pedal out the six miles without busting another tube.

This week, Northwest Trail Alliance members and cycling advocates citywide have their own blow out to recover from.

Last Thursday, after more than a year’s worth of debate on the issue, Commissioner Fish announced that there would be no new trail access for mountain bikers in Forest Park. At least not yet.

Instead, Fish, who had initially been quoted as saying that he wasn’t interested in studying the issue to death, ultimately decided that what is needed now are two more years of park study, outreach, and education before any changes will be made.

[Read Fish’s complete statement here]

Notwithstanding a nebulous pledge to enhance a pair of unnamed firelanes for riding within the next two years, Fish’s decision effectively mothballs nine months worth of tooth-and-nail progress made by the 15-member Singletrack Advisory Committee. The committee had been convened last August in order to find short-term solutions to the expansion issue.

Despite their differences, the committee, which included members from Northwest Trail Alliance, The Portland Audubon Society, and various other park stakeholders, had produced a list of options for the city to run with, including the addition of another trailhead to relieve the perpetual overcrowding on Leif Erikson, and opening Gas Line Road, an obscure path below the Leif Erikson trail that’s not found on the natural resources map.

In total, the proposals would have provided more than 8 miles of new and or improved terrain to ride. And in the eyes of mountain bike advocates, those actions seemed pretty modest and could be done without any harm to the park or any of its users, especially considering that they had abandoned the hotly contested trail-sharing option all together.

“They were incremental, they would have been phased, and many of them were already included in the management plan,” says Tom Archer, NWTA’s president, of the plans that were at Fish’s disposal. “We were hoping that the Parks department would follow those recommendations, and to that extent, we’re very disappointed.”

[Read NWTA official statement regarding Commissioner Fish’s decision here]

Archer wasn’t the only one left with sour grapes. Within hours of Fish’s announcement, the League of American Bicyclists—the very same Washington D.C. bike advocacy group that bestowed Portland with its highly touted “Platinum” rating for bike friendliness in 2008—released a statement expressing their dissatisfaction with the city’s decision.

[Read the entire League of American Bicyclists statement here]

“It got our attention,” Andy Clarke, the League’s president told me from his D.C. office some 2,000 miles away on Friday. “It tells us two things. Number one: there’s still a lot of work to be done. And Number two: Portland may be good by comparison to almost any other city in the country, but it’s still far from ideal.”

The city’s lack of mountain biking experiences was already considered a chink in Portland’s biking armor—a deficit that the League, which claims some 300 local members and ties with 750 affiliated local organizations such as the Bicycle Transportation Alliance and the Portland Wheelmen, noted before awarding Portland its Platinum status. As to whether Fish’s decision will negatively affect the Rose City’s lofty bike rating, which is up for renewal in 2012, Clarke says he’s not sure.

“If ridership increases and other things continue to go in the right direction, then maybe it won’t,” he explains. “But if we learn a year or two from now, that other things are coming off the rails, then it might factor into it.”

But according to Commissioner Fish, Portland’s bike scene is right on track. And when I spoke to him Friday morning, he told me that the overwhelming sentiment he has received about his decision has been positive.

“People on all sides of this issue, were wondering how this would come out and if this was cooked,” says Fish, who had been dogged by claims of favoritism throughout the process. First, anti-singletrack elements were put off by out-of-turn statements he made to bikers at the outset of the debate, in which he seemed to pledge to significantly increase access for mountain bikers within the park.

And then, with tensions riding high after the City Club had released a damning report on the health of the park this spring, and with the discovery of an illegal trail built by scofflaw mountain bikers a few months prior, it was singletrack supporters who were wondering if Fish was beginning to cave to voices that claimed allowing more bike access would destroy the park.

But Fish says he had only one goal in mind.

“I don’t make decisions on the basis of doing spot polls on who’s for it and who’s against it,” he says. “My primary obligation is to be a good steward of Forest Park. And the decision we announced was our best judgment based on the evidence.”

Fish also tells me that the city’s renewed commitment to projects such as Gateway Green, a mountain bike “skills park” that’s set to be built on a vacant patch of land near I-205 and I-84, and the city’s pledge to improve the recreation experience at Powell Butte in Southeast Portland (Fish’s dedication to both plans were also announced on Thursday) are “huge wins” for the mountain biking community.

NWTA’s Tom Archer says he’s pleased about the peripheral projects, but he maintains that the city failed to show leadership on the real issue at hand: Forest Park.

“They kind of took a middle path,” he says of Fish’s announcement, while adding that the other projects aren’t substitutes for increased access in the city’s preeminent green space.

So while I have Commissioner Fish on the phone, I ask him why mountain bikers like Archer shouldn’t look at this process as a total failure.

“I can certainly understand the frustration of anybody that is impatient with progress,” he answers. “But if you’re an advocate of singletrack in Forest Park, this is a deferral, not a failure.”

Fish also defends his stance to me by stating that without bulletproof science on the park’s overall condition, the process of applying for permits for new trails inside Forest Park would result in a land use “civil war”, complete with lengthy reviews and endless appeals processes.

And what about all of the committee’s work—is it simply flushed down the drain, I ask?

“No,” he says. “I have a deep commitment to this agenda. It’s not like we’ve announced that the door has been closed to mountain biking in Forest Park. Quite the contrary, what we’ve said is, ‘Here’s the road map to getting to yes.’”

But for Forest Park singletrack advocates like Archer, and in a town where our top brass has, at best, inched along on hot button issues like Columbia Crossing and Memorial Coliseum, and completely missed the boat on the Portland Beavers, it’s hard to believe that road map doesn’t lead right into a ditch.

“We’ve been working on this for 20 years,” says Archer. “And it is just now being raised to a higher level of visibility.”

To keep the issue on the front burner, he tells me the group has a ride planned in Forest Park on October 16. “We’re calling it a rally of support,” Archer tells me when I ask if this is a protest ride. “We know that there are a lot people who share our views and our commitment. It’s not just a narrow demographic. We will continue to work on it. It’s going to take some time.”

And quite possibly someone who’s willing to step in with glue, duct tape, wrappers of goo, or whatever might be handy, to try and patch this whole mess back together.

Show Comments

More in Hiking & Biking

Cover Story

Trail City

Within 20 miles of downtown you’ll find an astonishing 1,200 miles of trails and 40,000 acres of parks and natural areas. as hiking season arrives, we celebrate our seamless connection to nature by mapping 32 places to get outside in every corner of

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 06/15/2012


Slide Show: Bloom Lake Trail

This Coast Range excursion offers lush forests of alders and maples, quiet green waters, and trout fishing a mere 45 minutes from Portland.

  • Published 10/09/2013


Tom McCall Preserve

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 08/14/2012


Slide Show: Mazama Trail to McNeil Point Shelter

Timberline Lodge isn’t the only handcrafted accommodation on the slopes of Mount Hood!

  • Published 07/11/2014


Kelley Point Park

  • By Randy Gragg
  • Published 08/14/2012


Frog Lake Buttes

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/19/2009

Things To Do

Class Act

Portland’s favorite birds head back to school.

  • Published 08/22/2012


Cherry Orchard Trail

A windswept meadow leads to an abandoned cherry orchard

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/19/2009

Trail of the Month

Tualatin River National Wildlife Refuge

This month, head over to the Tualatin River Wildlife Refuge to glimpse local fauna.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 04/30/2010

Trail of the Month

Oxbow Regional Park

Located just 30 minutes from downtown Portland, Oxbow Regional Park remains a surprisingly untamed destination. Red foxes, blacktail deer, bald eagles, blue herons—even black bears and cougars—roam among the 1,200-acre expanse. But it’s the wa

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 09/13/2010

Trail of the Month

Ridgefield National Wildlife Refuge

The Ridgefield wildlife complex includes more than 5,200 acres of marshes, ponds, sloughs, and lakes—a welcome sight to a staggering array of migratory birds.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 12/22/2010

Trail of the Month

Trout Lake Ice Cave

The Trout Lake Ice Cave in Washington state, is a lava tube glaciere, which boasts otherworldly icy pillars, columns and crystallized stalagmites.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 04/22/2011

Trail of the Month

Mount Defiance

Visit the highest point in the Columbia River Gorge for a stunning variety of views.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/20/2011

Trail of the Month

Little Huckleberry Mountain

Come for the berries and stay for the dramatic views on your hike up Little Huckleberry Mountain.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 08/19/2011

Trail of the Month

Ghost Lake

Ghost Lake: Where else would you hike in October?

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 09/21/2011

Trail of the Month

Cape Horn

Get a gorgeous view of the Gorge from Cape Horn.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 10/14/2011

Trail of the Month

Crown Zellerbach Trail

An old logging road near Scappoose provide hikers and bikers with a scenic sojourn.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 11/23/2011

Trail of the Month

Buzzard Point Trail

Hike to the Pioneer Woman's Grave and then go for tacos—just east of Government Camp.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 12/23/2011

Trail of the Month

EasyClimb Trail

The new bike trail at Cascade Locks is simple and scenic.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 01/26/2012

Trail of the Month

Fort to Sea Trail

The scenery changes quickly and there's a chance you'll spot some whales on this rugged ramble. Thar she blows!

  • By Zach Dundas and Brian Barker
  • Published 02/24/2012

Trail of the Month

Stacker Butte/Dalles Mountain Ranch

Fantastic flora and gorgeous views of the Three Sisters make Stacker Butte/Dalles Mountain Ranch a trail worth taking.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 03/23/2012

Trail of the Month

Tamanawas Falls

Day trippers will definitely fall for the visual stimuli on this captivating Mt. Hood National Forest hike.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 04/27/2012

Trail of the Month

L. L. “Stub” Stewart State Park

Mountain bike enthusiasts have a new singletrack trail to cycle through.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/23/2012

Trail of the Month

Bird Creek Meadows Trail

Gaze in wonder at the wildflowers and waterfalls along Bird Creek Meadows Trail.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 07/18/2012


Pass Play

Stuff a state park in your sock.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 12/02/2009


The Public Option

Metro looks for comments on the new Tonquin Trail

  • Published 12/10/2009


Going Gray

Grab the binoculars, there’s a herd of whales coming!

  • Published 12/18/2009


Green Acres

Metro kicks off the New Year in style

  • Published 01/08/2010


Hoe Down

Northwest Trail Alliance calls in the heavy artillery

  • Published 01/14/2010

"Mount St Helens"

High on Helens

Permits, anniversaries, and Twitter updates—Mount St. Helens greets 2010

  • Published 02/01/2010

Get Out

Cacheing In

The City of Gresham’s Heritage Trees are Full of History—and Hidden Treasure.

  • Published 03/01/2010


America the Free

The country’s national parks offer a priceless experience—literally.

  • Published 03/30/2010


Fit to be Tied

Last week’s gubernatorial environmental debate has both democratic candidates seeing green

  • Published 04/06/2010


Big Wheels Keep on Turnin’

Don’t let Portland’s diminished bike ranking keep you down.

  • Published 04/07/2010

Mountain Biking

Logical Choice

Timberline teams up with world-famous Whistler Mountain Bike Park designer

  • Published 04/09/2010

Mountain Biking


Is more singletrack riding in Forest Park’s future?

  • Published 04/20/2010

Mountain Biking

Talk to me

Portland Parks opens its ears for comments about more singletrack in Forest Park

  • Published 04/28/2010


Hike of the Week: Dry Creek Falls

  • Published 05/11/2010


Broken Spoke

Portland’s Bike Cred Takes Another Knock

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/19/2010

Weekend Plans

Rain Check

Cash in on a free campsite during State Parks Day—just don’t forget your rain gear.

  • Published 06/02/2010

News and Notes

Chetco Uh-Oh

One of Oregon’s Wild and Scenic Rivers is headed for troubled waters.

  • Published 06/03/2010


Gear Shed

June’s rain got you down? Seek shelter in Columbia’s new Hotshot II shell.

  • Published 06/09/2010


Pedal it (just a little bit)

The vaguely interested outdoor lover’s guide to Pedalpalooza

  • Published 06/10/2010


Gear Guide

Keen’s Newport DP pack is one cushy ride

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 06/16/2010

News and Notes

Lost in the Woods

After a year of debate, there’s still no clear path for more singletrack in Forest Park

  • Published 06/18/2010

News and Notes

Here’s Mud in Your Eye

One night only! The Mudeye Puppet Company goes wild in Tryon Creek State Park

  • Published 06/21/2010

News and Notes

Park Place

Eastside bike parking gets a major upgrade

  • Published 06/24/2010

Field Report

Hike of the Week: Silver Star Mountain

Trek into the heart of the Gifford Pinchot National Forest for one of the area’s best wildflower displays.

  • Published 07/01/2010


All in Agreement

The City and the Forest Park Conservancy draft a plan to tackle the trails together.

  • By Lauren Fox
  • Published 07/21/2010


Serve St. Helens

Mount St. Helens institute asks avid hikers to treck the trails with intention.

  • By Lauren Fox
  • Published 08/03/2010

Field Report

Hike of the Week: Opal Creek

The Dog Days of Summer call for miles of tree-shaded trails, deep green pools—and a water slide.

  • Published 08/17/2010

News and Notes

Singletrack Savior?

NPR travels to Oakridge to find out if mountain biking can save a town.

  • Published 08/16/2010


Hike of the Week: Oneonta Gorge

Get this Columbia River Gorge excursion while it’s hot.

  • Published 08/25/2010


Panther Creek Falls

Photo of the Week

  • Published 09/20/2010


Views from Larch Mountain

Photo of the Week

  • Published 09/28/2010


Skiing at Timberline, Mountain Biking at L.L. Stub Stewart and more

Weekend Plans

  • Published 10/01/2010


Hike of the Week: St Cloud Trail

Explore a homestead apple orchard in the Gorge

  • Published 09/29/2010


A Field Guide to Forest Park

OPB’s award-winning Oregon Field Guide focuses its lens on the city’s largest urban wilderness

  • Published 10/12/2010

Bike Trail Ride

Forest Park Singletrack Rally

Portland Cyclists Support Singletrack

  • Published 10/14/2010


Banks-Vernonia State Trail connection complete

Last link in place for the state’s first rails-to-trails path

  • Published 10/26/2010


Wax On

REI lays it on thick for the next week.

  • Published 11/10/2010


Like big trees? There’s an app for that.

Portland’s Heritage Trees fit right inside your iPhone.

  • Published 11/16/2010

Get Out

Here’s Mud in Your Beer

The Stanley Portland Cup is Your Last Chance of the Year to Experience Cyclocross Portland Style.

  • By Geoff Earl
  • Published 12/01/2010

Get Out

Singles Party

Northwest Trail Alliance preps for mountain bike season with a pair of singletrack trail build parties.

  • By Georgia Perry
  • Published 02/11/2011


Fee Busters

Tour the National Parks on the cheap this year.

  • By Georgia Perry
  • Published 01/06/2011


Mountain Toppers

Climb Mount Hood, Adams, or the Grand Teton in support of the American Lung Association

  • By Georgia Perry
  • Published 01/11/2011

Get Out

Mile Markers

Forest Park Conservancy launches All Trails Challenge 2011

  • Published 02/18/2011

Get Out

Friendly Gorge Hikes

Friends of the Columbia Gorge announces Spring Hiking Program

  • By Georgia Perry
  • Published 03/03/2011

Mountain Bikes

Speak Now – Ride Later

Forest Service seeks public’s comments on Timberline’s proposed Mountain Bike Park.

  • Published 03/17/2011

Mountain Biking

Pedal Driven

New "Bike-umentary" launches Northwest Trail Alliance Trail Fest weekend

  • Published 04/18/2011


Forest Park on your iPhone

Forest Park Conservancy launches Forest Park iPhone app.

  • Published 09/02/2011


The Right Path

These scenic vistas, shot by _Portland Monthly_ staffer Scott Weber should get you out the door and into the wild. This June, he focuses on waterfall-filled hikes in the Columbia Gorge. What could be better than all this hair-blowing beauty less than an h

  • Published 05/26/2009


Trail of the Month: Baskett Slough

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 08/23/2012


True Grit

There's room to move in this grueling cycle sport where riders outnumber fans.

  • By Shoshanna Cohen
  • Published 12/16/2011

Trail of the Month

Butte Creek Falls Trail

Activity: Waterfall & Fall-color Viewing | Distance: About 1 mile, round trip | Rating: Moderate

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 09/21/2012

Trail of the Month

Aldrich Butte Trail

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 10/16/2012


Alameda Ridge Trail

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 11/20/2012


School Canyon Trail & Ball Point

Spot spring wildflowers and take in farmland views on this sunny-side Mount Hood trail.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 03/22/2013


Cedar Butte Trail

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/01/2013


Hood River Mountain Trail

Views of the craggy mountain, rustic barns, and fields of wildflowers may have you singing "the hills are alive..."

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 06/03/2013


Circumnavigate Mount Hood by Foot or by Bike!

We've mapped out the possibilities for your Mount Hood summer adventure.

  • By Christopher Van Tilburg
  • Published 07/01/2013


Rock of Ages Ridge Trail

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 07/01/2013


Cool Creek Trail

Hike to a retired fire lookout atop Devils Peak and enjoy towering firs, leafy rhododendrons, and huckleberry patches along the way.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 09/03/2013


Eightmile Loop Trail #496

A Hood River-area mountain biking trail for experts and beginners alike

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 10/01/2013

BEST OF 2013

Take a Hike! 2013's Top 12 Trails

Oregon is chock full of epic hiking destinations and scenic vistas to explore—and we’ve rounded up our favorites.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 12/19/2013


Trail of the Month: Hamilton Mountain

This challenging trail offers spring wildflowers, waterfalls, and wilderness—all just 45 minutes from Portland.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/01/2014


Portland Crowned King of Bike Commuting

A new report by the US Census Bureau shows that more Portlanders bike to work than residents of any major US city.

  • By Caleb Diehl
  • Published 05/29/2014


16 Perfect Trails for Exploring Mount St. Helens

Whether you're scouting for a family-friendly stroll or a three-day backpacking challenge, we've rounded up the best hiking opportunities on the volcano's west, east, and south sides.

  • By Maya Seaman, Aaron Scott, and Rachel Ritchie
  • Published 06/02/2014


8 Great Afternoon Hikes and Rides

Five trails and three bike routes that celebrate Northwest splendor—without the long haul.

  • Published 07/21/2014


Your Game Plan For Summitting St. Helens, Hood, and Adams

A trio of nearby peaks beckon—here’s how beginners can start their ascent.

  • By Devan Schwartz
  • Published 07/21/2014


The Ultimate Mount Hood Hiking Route

Circumnavigate our favorite Cascade peak for an unforgettable forest adventure.

  • By Christopher Van Tilburg
  • Published 07/14/2014


Trail of the Month: Indian Heaven Trail No. 33

Packed with glassy lakes, serene meadows, and alpine vistas, Southwest Washington’s Indian Heaven Wilderness is indeed divine.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 09/26/2014


Trail of the Month: Mosier Plateau

Wildflowers, waterfalls, and panoramic views—what more could you ask for? Plus 3 springtime travel ideas not to miss!

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 04/02/2015


Hoyt Arboretum

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 05/19/2009

Bird Watch

Rapt Attention

Red-tailed hawk chicks set for their debut on KGW’s Raptor Cam.

  • Published 04/21/2011


Take Ten

Columbia’s new iPhone app has you covered ten ways to Sunday.

  • Published 01/05/2011


Tualatin Valley Scenic Bikeway

Oregon's newest scenic bikeway offers 50 miles of horse pastures, pioneer cemeteries, and wetlands.

  • By Brian Barker
  • Published 08/01/2013

Related Content