Dawkins on God, Critics on Dawkins

The prominent—and controversial—New Atheist joins PSU Professor Peter Boghossian on stage for an evening of science and secularism.

By Rene Bermudez June 4, 2015

Richard Dawkins: taking on God this Friday at the Newmark.

Image: Portland5

Richard Dawkins, superstar atheist and author of best-seller The God Delusion, is on the defensive a lot lately. If you Google his name, the top several news results catch him insisting, for example, that he isn’t an “angry atheist” and that he doesn’t “despise individuals, but…”.

Another pointed headline also pops up: Salon’s recent “New Atheism’s Fatal Arrogance," which takes Dawkins and other secularists to task for “glaring intellectual laziness,” and has gathered 6,000 Facebook shares and over 1,000 comments. But “under attack” seems right in Dawkins’ comfort zone; joining him in the trenches this Friday at the Newmark is comrade-in-arms Peter Boghossian—a Portland State University philosophy professor and certainly no wilting flower himself—for what's sure to be a rousing public conversation on atheism, religion, and science. (That is, if Dawkin's Portland reception is even one fraction as frought as a 2010 visit from the late, irate Christopher Hitchens.)

Dawkins, an Oxford biologist, rose to prominence in the 2000s on the crest of a wave that came to be called “New Atheism” (see also: Sam Harris's 2004 book The End of Faith, Daniel Dennett’s Breaking the Spell (2006), and, in 2007, God Is Not Great, by Hitchens). At the movement’s core was the proposition that religious belief is false, and that eliminating false beliefs through scientific and rational inquiry creates a better world. In 2013, Boghossian’s A Manual for Creating Atheists went a step further, outlining how rationalists should engage believers, with the goal of convincing them to give up their faith—in other words, a form of reverse-evangelizing.

PSU Professor Peter Boghossian joins Dawkins on stage.

Yet the gloss of popularity enjoyed by some New Atheists during the Bush administration—when rational thought did seem, at times, an endangered species—seems to have lost luster in recent years.

Hitchens notoriously courted controversy (calling the Iraq invasion, in 2005, "a war to be proud of"), but even Dawkins, on record distancing himself from Hitcehns in 2013, has encountered consistent trouble in social media and the blogosphere. Recent Dawkins blowback has ranged from chronic foot-in-mouth disease to 2011's explosive "Elevatorgate," in which Dawkins mocked atheist blogger Rebecca Watson for asking that men not hit on her in enclosed spaces like elevators.

Meanwhile, Boghossian recently raised eyebrows when he collaborated with anti-feminist "men's rights activist" Stefan Molyneux on a video that explicitly pits feminism against atheism.

Like all movements, New Atheism is changing with time. Dawkins and Boghossian's conversation will likely cover familiar ground, but it will also give Portlanders a look at where New Atheism is now and, perhaps, where it is headed. 

Richard Dawkins and Peter Boghossian, June 5 at 7:30 pm, Newmark Theatre

Filed under
Show Comments